Rutger McGroarty pushes for an opening-night roster, bringing size, forechecking, and offensive instinct that could translate to top-nine or PP exposure, making him a valuable late-round fantasy target if he wins minutes.

McGroarty is highlighted as a potential X-Generation piece, blending emotion and hustle to become a fan favorite and a tangible future contributor. His development is a focal point for Pittsburgh’s attempt to cultivate a short-term nucleus that can grow into a sustained competitive core.

McGroarty, 21, is Pittsburgh’s No. 1 under-25 asset, acquired from Winnipeg in 2024. He posted 39 points in 60 AHL games, finished strong with 20 in 24, and scored his first NHL goal in a late-season recall versus St. Louis. His leadership, two-way game, and power-forward toolkit position him for a long-term top-six role, especially under Muse’s development-driven plan.

Rutger McGroarty was traded to the Pittsburgh Penguins after refusing to sign with the Jets, reflecting the challenges the team has faced in securing top prospects.

McGroarty is viewed as a critical piece in the Penguins' future plans, expected to play a significant role in the team's youth movement.